Showing posts with label Art Appreciation. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Art Appreciation. Show all posts

I Know What I Like


The world’s art museums are testament to the pleasure felt by the public when viewing the great art of the current and previous civilizations. These days it is no longer sufficient to say, “I like that one” or “I don’t think much of that.” We need a more scientific or objective measure.

We now have a field of scientific endeavor call neuroaesthetics that works to unravel what the ‘little grey cells’ are doing when we stare at a nude by Jean-Auguste-Dominique Ingres. Prof. Zeki at U C London has started down the road to finding out what is going on inside our heads. His latest study was described in the UK’s daily telegraph (1).

A group of volunteers were stuffed headfirst, one at a time, into MRI machines to have their medial orbitofrontal cortex watched while they were shown images of old masters at intervals of ten seconds. Now our medial orbitofrontal cortex is the part of our brain in which we experience pleasure and desire. Increased blood flow indicates that we are working those little grey cells hard.

There were no surprises in that artists like Ingres and Constable caused to greatest rush of blood to the head. Viewing pictures by artists such as Quentin Matsys caused the least excitement. A reproduction in oil of his ‘The Ugly Duchess’ is available from the Oil Painting Factory (2), so you can try the experiment for yourself and see if your medial orbitofrontal cortex gets overheated.
'The Ugly Duchess, Quentin Matsys
photo National Gallery, London
The effects of the beautiful pictures was sufficiently strong that the suggestion was made that art should be made as widely available as possible to the general public where ever they are. However, this begs the question as to who is going to choose, and what are  they going to choose to keep us looking, at if the aim is to keep us topped up with feelings of pleasure and desire from morning ‘till night. I, for one, am unsure if I can survive such sensory overload. We will have to have a sufficient smattering of ‘ugly art’ added into the mix.











  1. http://www.telegraph.co.uk/culture/art/art-news/8500012/Brain-scans-reveal-the-power-of-art.html
  2. http://www.oilpaintingfactory.com/english/oil-painting-102133.htm

    Art Students


    Java sparrow                Photo: Kim Bridges, Picassa Web Albums


    For artists and gallery owners, Art (with a capital A) is a serious business. For many though, it is a matter of decoration, chosen on the basis of “I know what I like”. There are examples of paintings by elephants and chimpanzees selling for appreciable sums. To, I hasten to add,  people and not to fellow elephants or primates other than of the human persuasion.

    It is possible to train or condition most species to recognize or respond to a variety of shapes and colors. But do species have preferences for types of human artistic endeavors? Prof. Watanabe and his colleague at Keio U have set out to answer this question (1). They chose a team of seven Java sparrows to live in an art gallery style cage with images of three artistic styles. The first was, of course, traditional Japanese art, and the other two were Cubist and Impressionist painting styles. Perching time in front of the images was used to score preferences.

    Five of the seven preferred Cubism to Impressionism. There was a three to two split on Japanese traditional to Cubist images. When asked if they preferred Impressionism to trad Japanese painting, six didn’t give a hoot, or in their case a chipchipchip.

    Of course, none of the birds had been exposed to an art appreciation course, and so they were then enrolled in a program. They were subjected to a positive and negative reward system of teaching that is similar to the operant conditioning that we often subject our children to. At the end of the program, the sparrows could discriminate between the styles and were graduated. The question remains though: where they really, deep down, preferring some of the images or were the just parroting what they had been told?


    Y. Ikkarai & S Watanabe, Animal Cognition, 14, 227-234, (2011). DOI: 10.1007/s10071-010-0356-3