Showing posts with label Testosterone Levels. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Testosterone Levels. Show all posts

Digit Ratios Are Back


Wall Street and the trading floors of similar establishments throughout the world are populated with traders who are well known for their willingness to take risks. Their expectations are high and their bonuses are large. Studies have reportedly shown that the testosterone levels in the saliva of the traders are higher than the normal average level (1).

Our old friend the 2D:4D digit ratios of the traders were also on the low side of average. So the concept is that the babies were set up to take risks before they were born and subsequently pointed at the stock exchanges and set loose to go get ‘em, tiger.

To be successful, it’s not just low risk aversion that’s required, but they do need good reasoning ability too, at least in an ideal world without poisonous derivatives. So Brañas-Garza and Rustichini decided to check this can of worms to see how risk aversion and reasoning ability interact. They selected 188 students of whom almost two thirds were women and set about measuring their fingers.

With their digit ratios established, they played lottery games to establish their risk aversion and did sets of multiple-choice papers to measure their reasoning abilities.

The first point to note is that the women’s fingers didn’t give much joy. Correlations weren’t strong enough and also were, if any, opposite to what was expected from the guys.

For the guys, low 2D:4D indicated low risk aversion. So far, so good, just like the traders and as expected. But now we have a surprise. A low digit ratio also corresponded to higher reasoning scores. Hence, we have an explanation as to how the high-risk takers survive in the trading world. The suggestion is that they process data better so the risks aren’t as risky as you and I might think – well some of the time anyway, but not lately.

So the next time you go to visit with your financial adviser, take your ruler along to check the 2D:4D ratio of his digits. If your financial adviser is a woman, you’ll need to read a different paper. This one claims that the mediating effect of reasoning ability on lack of risk aversion was absent for the female subjects.

Maybe we should look at job performance rather than the length of fingers. Or maybe it would be better to stuff our mattresses with our spare cash (if we have any left.)

  1. http://www.plosone.org/article/info%3Adoi%2F10.1371%2Fjournal.pone.0029842


Please note that this blog is migrating to
in 2 days.

Taming The Beast


The old fogies whose job it is to advise, are still advising young men that they should settle down and raise a family. Mostly, we humans accept that raising kids has to be a cooperative process and get on and help as best they can. The whole process of falling in love and then raising a family involves a major change in activity.

But it is made easier for us guys to make the changes. We don’t have to fight the testosterone as much as we fear before we set about this sort of enterprise. Gettler et al in this week’s Proceedings of the National Academy of Science (1) have followed the testosterone levels in a large number of young men in the Philippines and compared their levels before and after they’ve settled down to raise kids. They show that there is a large drop in testosterone by a quarter to a third on getting a partner and producing a child.

These authors put this taming of the beast down to fatherhood and this news has been bouncing around the blogosphere in the last couple of days, but an Italian team from the U of Pisa (2) pointed out that fatherhood is not required to lower a guy’s testosterone level. They showed that falling in love was all that is required for him to become as quiet as a lamb.

Their results were very interesting as the showed that the men’s T-level dropped while the women’s T-level rose. Yes, interesting, when one thinks about the action of testosterone on our social behavior.

The study showed that the effect of love (on their T-levels) had worn off after a year – just in time for the fatherhood lever to come into play to drop the level and keep him from risky behavior. This hormonal change on becoming a dad was originally identified as early as 2001 (3), but it’s nice to see it being confirmed again.

  1. http://www.pnas.org/content/early/2011/09/02/1105403108.abstract
  2. D.Marazzati and D.Canale, Psychoneurendocrinology, 29, 931, (2004).
  3. S.J.Berg and K.E.Wynne-Edwards, Mayo Clinic Proceedings, 76, 582, (2001).